Alkaline Water Machine vs. Pitcher: Which is Best for You? 

December 09, 2022 5 min read

Alkaline Water Machine vs. Pitcher: Which is Best for You? 

You’ve probably heard a lot of talk in health and wellness circles recently about alkaline water. Alkaline water has a higher pH level than regular tap water, meaning it is less acidic and can have positive health benefits. If you're thinking about switching to alkaline water, you might wonder which option is best: an alkaline water machine or an alkaline water filter pitcher? Both options offer significant health benefits but work in different ways and come with different costs. Keep reading to learn more about each option so you can make an informed decision for your needs. 

Why Would You Want to Drink Alkaline Water? 

Alkaline water has some significant health benefits over regular drinking water, which makes it an attractive option for many consumers. It contains antioxidants, which can help reduce inflammation and improve overall health. Additionally, alkaline water helps neutralize the body's acid. It can help to restore the body's natural pH balance, which is essential for optimal health and well-being. 

Benefits of Drinking Alkaline Water 

The many potential benefits of drinking alkaline water make it attractive to health-conscious consumers. A few key advantages include the following:  

  • Improving your hydration levels  
  • Reducing inflammation  
  • Enhancing nutrient absorption  
  • Promoting better digestion  
  • Boosting energy levels  
  • Supporting a healthy immune system  

What is an Alkaline Water Machine?  

A water ionizer is the most common type of alkaline machine on the market today. It works by passing electricity through a chamber filled with electrodes that separate the positive and negative ions in tap water. This process produces an alkaline water filtration system capable of removing chlorine, chloramines, and some other contaminants from water while raising its pH level. 

What Is an Alkaline Water Filter Pitcher? 

An alkaline water filter pitcher is a popular alternative to an ionizer machine. It uses a carbon-based filter to remove impurities and raise the pH level of regular tap or bottled water. A filter pitcher does not remove any healthy minerals from your water. Instead, it retains those minerals and adds additional healthy minerals to raise the overall pH of your water. Most importantly, a high quality alkaline filter pitcher will also remove acidic contaminants from your water.

Alkaline Water Machines vs. Alkaline Water Pitchers  

When choosing between an alkaline water machine and an alkaline water filter pitcher, there are a few things to consider. 


Alkaline water machines tend to be more expensive than pitchers due to their larger size and multiple stages of filtration. On average, an alkaline water machine will cost anywhere from $200-$1000, depending on the size and type of filter. Alkaline water pitchers cost about $50-$100 and are more affordable for most households.  

Filtration Capabilities 

    Both an alkaline machine and a pitcher are capable of removing contaminants from water while raising the pH level. However, an alkaline filter pitcher is more effective at filtering out heavy metals and certain other impurities than an alkaline machine. For instance, the Seychelle Gen 2 Dual pH2O Pure Water Pitcher has been tested to remove up to 99.99% of tap water contaminants, including Lead, Arsenic, Chromium 6, MTBEs/TTHMs, VOCs/chemical residues, and up to 90% of Fluoride.

    Pros and Cons 

    Alkaline Water Machines 


    • Alkaline water machines can raise the pH level of your water 9 or above, which is the ideal range for alkaline water.  
    • Machines typically have a larger storage capacity than pitchers, so they're better suited for families or households with several people.  
    • Machines often come with filters that remove some contaminants like chlorine that affect that taste and odor of your water.


    • Alkaline water machines are usually more expensive than pitchers. A high-quality machine can cost thousands of dollars, while a quality pitcher typically costs about $80. 
    • Not all machines come with filters, so you'll want to check before you buy to see if yours does.  
    • Most machines are not tested to remove heavy metals and other contaminants from your water like the Seychelle pitcher is. 

    Alkaline Water Filter Pitchers 


    • Alkaline water pitchers are usually more affordable than machines; a quality pitcher typically costs around $80, while a high-quality machine can cost thousands of dollars.
    • Pitchers typically have a smaller storage capacity than machines, so they're better suited for households with no more than four or five people.
    • Pitchers are portable, so you can enjoy and share alkaline water outside of your house, or you can check out an alkaline filter bottle.
    • The Seychelle pitcheris tested to remove heavy metals and other contaminants from your drinking water; most machines are not tested for this purpose.  


    • Alkaline water pitchers can only raise the pH level of your drinking water to 8 or 9.5; if you want a higher pH level, you may need to buy a machine.   


    Q: What is the difference between alkaline water and regular tap water?  

    A: Alkaline water has a higher pH level than regular tap water. Many people drink alkaline water daily in order to improve their health and energy levels.  

    Q: Is an alkaline water machine better than a filter pitcher?  

    A: Both options have their pros and cons. An alkaline water machine holds more filtered alkaline water at any given time but tends to be much more expensive than pitchers. They also may not have the filtration capabilities that a pitcher does.

    Q: Can I make my own alkaline water? 

    A: Yes, you can make your own alkaline water at home using a simple kitchen pitcher

    The Verdict  

    So, which is better – an alkaline water machine or an alkaline water pitcher? The answer depends on your needs and preferences. Both machines and pitchers are capable of producing quality alkaline water. If you're looking for a bulky way to get alkaline water, then an alkaline water machine is the way to go. However, if you're looking for a more budget-friendly option and convenient way to drink alkaline water, then an alkaline water pitcher might be a better choice. Ultimately, the decision comes down to your individual needs and preferences. 

    Key Takeaway 

    It is clear that an alkaline water filter pitcher is the better option for most consumers. Not only does it cost less than a water ionizer, but it also has comparable filtration capabilities without needing to use electricity. Additionally, pitchers can easily be used with any type of drinking water and replaced when needed, making them very convenient compared to an alkaline machine. For these reasons, we recommend an alkaline water filter pitcher over an alkaline water machine. 


    The importance of quality drinking water is undeniable. If you're looking for an alkaline water solution that is both effective and affordable, we recommend choosing an alkaline water pitcher over an alkaline water machine. When selecting a pitcher, be sure to find one that has been tested to remove contaminants like heavy metals and other contaminants from your water. 

    Works Cited: